At thirty-five, Confucius witnessed political chaos in Lu state: Duke Zhao was driven into exile by the powerful Three Huan clans – Jisun, Mengsun, and Shusun – who vied for control, destabilizing the state. Disillusioned, Confucius traveled to Qi, hoping Duke Jing of Qi – who aspired to emulate the legendary hegemon Duke Huan of Qi – would adopt his vision of virtuous governance.
Frustration and Setback in Qi
Though Duke Jing received him courteously, he consulted Yan Ying (Yanzi), Qi’s famed minister. In 531 BC, when Yanzi was on a diplomatic mission to Chu, King Chu repeatedly tried to humiliate him, but Yanzi outwitted him each time. Feeling ashamed, the king sent Yanzi back to Qi with rich gifts.
While Yanzi admired Confucius’s character and learning, their philosophies diverged: Yanzi favored pragmatic statecraft; Confucius insisted on ritual and moral principle. Yanzi’s stance was clear:
“Respect him, but keep your distance.”
Without strong support, Confucius remained unused.
After nearly three years in Qi, he returned to Lu, dedicating himself to teaching. His school flourished – 72 disciples would later be hailed as “men of outstanding attainment.” To them, Confucius was not just a teacher but a father figure, bound by deep mutual respect.
The Call to Jia Valley
In 500 BCE, Duke Jing of Qi sought to revive Qi’s hegemony by forging an alliance with Lu and other states. He invited Duke Ding of Lu to a summit at Jia Valley (modern Laiwu, Shandong) to seal a covenant.
Such meetings required a “Xiangli” – a chief minister to assist the ruler in ritual and negotiation. When Duke Ding asked who should serve, a minister proposed Kong Qiu, now Minister of Justice (Da Sikou) – the renowned Confucius.
By 501 BCE, at age fifty-one, Confucius had risen through Lu’s ranks: first as Magistrate of Zhongdu, then Minister of Works (Sikong), and finally Minister of Justice. His administrative competence and moral authority made him the natural choice.
Preparing for Deceit: “Peace Requires Arms”
Anticipating treachery, Confucius warned Duke Ding:
“Qi relies on military might. Remember Duke Xiang of Song, who attended a meeting unarmed – and was humiliated by Chu. Peace without defense invites aggression.”
He urged bringing troops. Duke Ding agreed. Confucius arranged for generals Shenju Xu and Le Qi to lead 500 chariots, stationed ten li from the summit site – close enough to intervene, far enough to avoid provocation.
At the meeting, only a few guards accompanied the Lu delegation onto the platform, while the main force remained hidden but ready.
Note: In 639 BC, the feudal lords convened a meeting at Yu (present-day northwest Suixi County, Henan Province). Duke Xiang of Song intended to establish his hegemony through this meeting. However, King Cheng of Chu violated the agreement, ordered his hidden soldiers to arrest Duke Xiang, and led an army to attack Song, which failed. Duke Xiang was later released through the mediation of Qi and Lu.
The First Trap: Barbarian dancers
After formal rites, Duke Jing of Qi, with Yanzi as his Xiangli, announced:
“To honor this rare gathering, I present a special performance!”
Suddenly, drumbeats thundered. A troupe of men dressed as “barbarians” – waving spears, swords, and shields – charged the stage, shouting wildly. Duke Ding turned pale with fear.
Confucius sprang forward, confronting Duke Jing:
“When civilized states meet, entertainment must reflect decorum – not mimic savage warfare! Order them off at once!”
Yanzi, unaware of the plot (orchestrated by Qi minister Li Mi), concurred:
“Indeed! We do not enjoy such spectacles.”
Embarrassed, Duke Jing dismissed the performers. Li Mi’s plan – to frighten Lu into concessions – had failed.
The Second Insult: Lewd performers
At the post-summit banquet, Li Mi struck again. He sent in painted, perfumed entertainers who sang bawdy songs and performed indecent gestures – a deliberate insult to Lu’s dignity.
Enraged, Confucius drew his sword, glaring at Duke Jing:
“These lowly men mock sovereigns! They deserve death. Command your marshal to execute them!”
When Qi remained silent, Confucius declared:
“Since Qi and Lu are now sworn brothers, Lu’s marshals may enforce justice here!”
He shouted:
“Where are Shenju Xu and Le Qi?”
The two generals rushed in, seized the ringleaders, and dragged them away. The rest fled in terror. Duke Jing was stunned; Yanzi calmed him. Li Mi, realizing Lu’s army was nearby, slunk away in fear.
Diplomatic victory and Territorial restitution
Afterward, Yanzi rebuked Li Mi fiercely and advised Duke Jing:
“If you truly seek hegemony through righteousness, return the lands you seized from Lu – specifically the three districts of Fenyang.”
Duke Jing complied. The territories were restored. Duke Ding expressed gratitude, and the Lu delegation returned home in triumph.
The golden age of Confucian governance
Confucius’s conduct at Jia Valley earned him unprecedented trust from Duke Ding and even the Three Huan clans. He was entrusted with overall administration of state affairs.
Historical texts like the Records of the Grand Historian (Shiji) and Zuo Zhuan recount that within just three months, Lu transformed:
- Lost items left on roads were untouched – no one stole.
- Homes slept with doors open – no thieves dared enter.
- Public order and moral integrity flourished.
It was a brief but luminous era – proof that ritual, justice, and virtue could govern as effectively as armies and laws.
Leave a Reply