Chapter 40 of Romance of the Three Kingdoms depicts a moment of profound crisis and moral clarity. With Liu Biao’s death, the fate of Jing Province, one of the last great strongholds of the crumbling Han dynasty, hangs in the balance. What follows is a chain of betrayal, strategic brilliance, and unwavering compassion: Cai family treachery, Zhuge Liang’s fiery defense, and Liu Bei’s legendary mercy toward civilians.
While Luo Guanzhong heightens drama for narrative effect, historical sources like Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi) corroborate the core events – revealing how realpolitik and idealism clashed on the road to Red Cliffs.
The death of Liu Biao and the coup in Xiangyang
As Liu Biao lies dying, he expresses his wish to entrust Jing Province to Liu Bei, recognizing his virtue and capability. But Liu Bei, ever mindful of propriety and wary of appearing opportunistic, politely declines, saying:
“Your sons are grown; how could I presume to take their inheritance?”
Soon after, Liu Biao passes away. Seizing the moment, Lady Cai and her brother Cai Mao immediately install the younger son, Liu Cong, as ruler – concealing Liu Biao’s death from both Liu Qi (the rightful heir) and Liu Bei.
This swift coup reflects not just familial ambition, but the Cai clan’s deep ties to northern interests – and their fear of Cao Cao’s growing power.
Historically, the Sanguozhi confirms that Liu Cong succeeded under Cai influence, and that Liu Bei was kept in the dark – a detail underscoring the fragility of alliances in late-Han politics.
Surrender without a fight: The Betrayal of Jingzhou
When Cao Cao learns of Liu Biao’s death, he launches an immediate southern campaign with overwhelming force. Panic-stricken, Lady Cai and Liu Cong decide to surrender Jing Province without resistance, hoping to secure favor and safety under Wei.
They send Song Zhong to deliver the instrument of surrender to Cao Cao’s camp. But en route, Song Zhong is intercepted by Guan Yu, who brings him before Liu Bei. Only then does Liu Bei learn that Jing Province has already fallen – not in battle, but through capitulation.
Devastated yet resolute, Liu Bei prepares to abandon Xinye and flee south toward Jiangling, where military supplies and ships await.
The Burning of Xinye
Though forced to retreat, Zhuge Liang refuses to leave passively. He orchestrates a brilliant delaying action:
- All civilians are evacuated in advance.
- The city of Xinye is left eerily empty – a trap disguised as abandonment.
- When Cao Ren and Cao Hong lead Cao Cao’s vanguard into the city, they celebrate prematurely.
- That night, hidden troops ignite fire attacks on all sides – flames engulfing barracks, stables, and supply lines.
- As chaos erupts, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun launch coordinated assaults from ambush positions.
- During Cao Ren’s retreat, Liu Bei’s forces strike again, inflicting heavy casualties.
This Battle of Xinye – though modest in scale – is portrayed as Zhuge Liang’s first large-scale tactical masterpiece, proving his worth beyond theory.
Historically, while the Sanguozhi mentions skirmishes during Liu Bei’s retreat, it attributes no specific fire attack at Xinye to Zhuge Liang. Scholars believe Luo Guanzhong dramatized or invented this episode to showcase Zhuge Liang’s early impact – much like the Bowang Slope incident.
The retreat with the people
With Xinye ablaze behind them, Liu Bei leads a mass exodus toward Jiangling – but unlike other warlords, he refuses to abandon the civilian refugees who follow him.
Tens of thousands march slowly, burdened by carts and children. His officers urge haste:
“Cao Cao’s cavalry will overtake us! Leave the people and save yourself!”
But Liu Bei replies with iconic resolve:
“To raise an army is to protect the people. How can I forsake them for my own survival?”
This act – prioritizing compassion over expediency – becomes central to Liu Bei’s image as the Confucian ideal of the benevolent ruler. It also slows his retreat, setting the stage for the disaster at Changban in the next chapter.
Historical records confirm Liu Bei did flee with civilians, though likely fewer than the novel claims. Still, the gesture was real – and rare among warlords of the era.
The moral high ground in a ruthless age
Chapter 40 juxtaposes two visions of power:
- Cao Cao: conquest through intimidation and surrender.
- Liu Bei: leadership through sacrifice and humanity.
While Cao Cao gains territory, Liu Bei gains legitimacy in the eyes of history. And with Zhuge Liang now at his side, even defeat becomes a prelude to resurgence.
Leave a Reply