The Master said, “For one who never asks, ‘What should I do? What should I do?’ I, for my part, can do nothing about him.”
Note
Though simple in wording, this saying from the Analects of Confucius profoundly reveals his emphasis on active thinking, self-awareness, and the learner’s initiative.
“What should I do?” expresses a person’s puzzlement, reflection, and desire to find solutions when facing difficulties. Confucius believed that someone who never raises such questions shows a lack of self-awareness, unwillingness to think, and indifference to their own condition – remaining passive or numb.
Toward such a person, even Confucius himself admits, “I can do nothing about him”, because effective teaching requires the learner’s willingness to seek understanding and change. Without inner motivation, external instruction is like playing the lute to a cow – utterly futile.
This underscores the subjectivity of learning and moral cultivation: ethical growth is not the result of passive indoctrination but arises from inner questioning, inquiry, and exploration. True education begins with asking questions, not merely receiving answers.
It also aligns with Confucius’ pedagogical principle in Analects 7.8: “I do not enlighten those who are not eager to learn, nor prompt those who are not struggling to articulate their thoughts.” A student must first experience genuine intellectual urgency (“fury” and “frustration”) before a teacher can effectively guide them. If one never even asks “What should I do?”, they are not yet ready to be taught.
Today, this warning is especially relevant: in an age of information overload, many people passively consume ready-made answers but lose the ability to formulate meaningful questions. Yet true wisdom always begins with a sincere inquiry into “What should I do?”
In short, Confucius teaches: Without perplexity, there is no awakening; without asking, there is no teachability; active questioning is the first step toward growth.
Further Reading
The Master said, “I do not enlighten those who are not eager to learn, nor prompt those who are not struggling to articulate their thoughts. If I show one corner of a square and they cannot return with the other three, I will not repeat it.” Analects 7.8 (Shu Er)
Both stress that effective teaching depends on the learner’s active engagement and inner drive to understand.
子曰：「不曰『如之何如之何』者，吾末如之何也已矣。」
Leave a Reply