In the turbulent era of ancient China, a story unfolded between the powerful warlord Cao Cao and the renowned physician Hua Tuo, a tale filled with ambition, misunderstanding, and tragic consequences.
Hua Tuo was no ordinary doctor. His early life was marked by opportunities in the officialdom. First, he was recommended as an up-and-coming talent by Chen Gui, the father of Chen Deng, who was the Prefect of Pei at that time and later the Grand Administrator of Guangling, holding the title of General Who Pacifies the Waves in Wei. Subsequently, Huang Wan, the Grand Commandant, also invited him to take an official post. However, due to the chaotic state of the world, Hua Tuo declined both offers and did not enter the official career.
Hua Tuo’s medical skills were renowned far and wide. As early as in the Eastern Han Dynasty, he was capable of performing abdominal surgery. He could open the abdomen and then suture it with needles and threads, a technique that seems almost identical to modern medical practices. Moreover, the “Mafeisan” he invented was the world’s earliest pure Chinese – medicine surgical anesthetic known to date, boasting miraculous effects.
In Luo Guanzhong’s Romance of the Three Kingdoms, there is a vivid description of Hua Tuo scraping the poison off Guan Yu’s bone. It is said that during the Battle of Xiangyang, Guan Yu was struck by a poisoned arrow from the Wei army. Hua Tuo cut open Guan Yu’s arm and scraped the poison from the bone, while Guan Yu remained calm, even playing chess with someone during the process. This passage not only portrays Guan Yu’s extraordinary courage but also showcases Hua Tuo’s superb medical skills. However, this is actually a fictional account by Luo Guanzhong. Although the incident of Guan Yu having the poison scraped from his bone is true, as recorded in Records of the Three Kingdoms – Biography of Guan Yu in the Book of Shu. According to historical inferences, this event should have occurred before the Battle of Xiangyang, not during it as described in Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Also, the doctor who performed this treatment was not Hua Tuo but a military doctor in Guan Yu’s army.
In Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Luo Guanzhong, in an attempt to highlight Cao Cao’s suspicious nature, wrongly attributed the credit for treating Guan Yu’s wound to Hua Tuo. Later, when Hua Tuo proposed performing a craniotomy on Cao Cao to cure his headache, Cao Cao became extremely suspicious. Connecting this with the story of Hua Tuo treating Guan Yu, he suspected that Hua Tuo intended to harm him and thus imprisoned and executed him.
In reality, the real reason for Hua Tuo’s death was his aspiration to pursue an official career. Hua Tuo was deeply ashamed of his identity as a doctor. Historical records state that
“originally being a literati, he engaged in the medical profession and often regretted it.”
Therefore, Hua Tuo was constantly on the lookout for opportunities to enter the officialdom. Unfortunately, everyone saw him merely as an excellent doctor, rather than a literati capable of engaging in politics.
Beneath his medical robes, he harbored the heart of a scholar – bureaucrat. Proficient in the teachings of Confucian classics, he considered the practice of medicine, which was regarded as a menial profession in the Eastern Han Dynasty, a stain on his aspirations. He was waiting for an opportunity that would truly fulfill his dreams of a glorious official career.
Enter Cao Cao. Plagued by a severe and persistent headache disorder known as “head – wind dizziness,” Cao Cao was desperate for a cure. Having heard of the extraordinary medical skills of his fellow – townsman Hua Tuo, he summoned the doctor to his side. Cao Cao’s intention was clear: to keep Hua Tuo as his personal imperial physician, a tool to relieve his pain.
Hua Tuo, however, felt deeply humiliated. Being at the beck and call of Cao Cao, merely to treat his ailments, was far from his vision of a fulfilling life. But he had little choice at the moment and began to treat Cao Cao.
As time passed, Hua Tuo grew increasingly desperate to escape this situation. He came up with a plan. He told Cao Cao that his wife was gravely ill and needed his immediate care, thus requesting leave. Cao Cao, in his need for Hua Tuo’s medical expertise, reluctantly granted it. But Hua Tuo had no intention of returning. He ignored Cao Cao’s repeated urgings to come back.
Cao Cao, suspicious by nature, sent people to secretly check on Hua Tuo. To his great anger, he discovered that Hua Tuo had been lying. His wife was not ill at all. Hua Tuo was promptly arrested and thrown into prison.
Xun Yu, a trusted advisor of Cao Cao, pleaded for Hua Tuo’s life, saying that such a skilled doctor was valuable. But Cao Cao, enraged by what he saw as Hua Tuo’s deception and defiance, scoffed at the idea. He saw Hua Tuo as an unruly and deceitful person.
There were deeper reasons for Cao Cao’s decision to execute Hua Tuo. First, Hua Tuo’s act of lying and disobeying orders was a blatant crime of deceiving the lord, a serious offense in Cao Cao’s eyes. Second, Cao Cao believed that Hua Tuo was deliberately “exaggerating his illness to raise his own status,” using Cao Cao’s pain as a means to gain more power and respect. Third, even in prison, Hua Tuo remained silent, never showing any sign of submission or regret. He refused to plead for mercy, which further infuriated Cao Cao. And finally, Hua Tuo failed to recognize his position in Cao Cao’s world. He still clung to his self – image as a noble scholar, not as a doctor at the service of the powerful warlord.
Hua Tuo’s tragic end was sealed. With his death, a great medical talent was lost. And later, when Cao Cao’s beloved son Cao Chong fell seriously ill and there was no one with the skills to save him, Cao Cao couldn’t help but regret his hasty decision to kill Hua Tuo. But it was too late. The story of Cao Cao and Hua Tuo serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us of the importance of understanding, communication, and the consequences of misjudgment.
Leave a Reply