In Strange Tales from Liaozhai – Tian Qilang, Lin Er’s series of actions—from overstepping boundaries due to his special status to completely trampling on ethics and loyalty—form a complete portrait of a “wicked servant.” These actions not only escalate the conflicts in the story but also expose, in an extreme way, the dark side of human nature entangled by desire and power.
Lin’er’s behaviors are not isolated moral failures but a progressive “logic of boundary-breaking”.
From privilege-dependent to active evil maker
An Extreme Violator of Ethical Order
Lin’er starts as “the catamite of his master Wu Chengxiu,” a status that grants him a special position in the Wu family. However, Lin’er distorts this special relationship into a “privilege that overrides ethics.” His attempt to rape his master’s daughter-in-law directly breaches the dual bottom lines of “the distinction between master and servant” and the law. This “illusion of privilege” in feudal ethics transforms him from an “adherent to authority” into a “destroyer of ethics.”
An Opportunist Dependent on Power
Every choice Lin’er makes is precisely aimed at maximizing “protection by power.” After his evil deeds are exposed, he neither confesses nor flees far; instead, he directly takes refuge with his master’s political enemy (the censor’s younger brother). This choice is highly opportunistic: he knows well that although Wu Chengxiu is wealthy, he lacks real power, while the censor’s family controls official power and can provide him with “legal immunity.” By transforming himself from “a wicked servant of the Wu family” into “a tool for the censor to confront the Wu family,” he successfully turns his personal guilt into a bargaining chip in power struggles.
This betrayal is no impulsive act but a precise exploitation of the feudal power structure—he sees through the reality that “power overrides law” and believes that “depending on stronger power” is the only way to survive. For this, he can completely sever ties with his former master (even though he once benefited from his protection) and even take the initiative to become a “blade” attacking his former master.
An Active Perpetrator Driven by Desire
Lin’er’s actions are always dominated by intense desires, which gradually escalate into a distorted psychology of “taking pleasure in hurting others.”
His attempt to rape his master’s daughter-in-law is a product of primitive lust combined with “the illusion of power”—he not only wants to satisfy his desires but also seeks to confirm his “special status” by “possessing his master’s relative.”
Insulting his former master at his door with arrogance and fabricating rumors of an affair are motivated by both revenge and the desire to curry favor: the former is a counterattack against “his former master’s pursuit of accountability,” while the latter is a pledge of loyalty to his new master (the censor’s younger brother). By humiliating his former master and tarnishing the Wu family’s reputation, he both vents his resentment at “being pursued” and proves his value to the new power with “destructive achievements.”
An Ungrateful Betrayer
Lin’er’s actions fundamentally subvert the bottom line of loyalty between master and servant in ancient society. Wu Chengxiu’s “special treatment” of him (taking him as a catamite) essentially includes “the grace of protection” (providing a livelihood and certain privileges). However, in times of crisis, he not only shows no gratitude but also betrays Wu by taking refuge with his enemy, insulting his former master, and framing the Wu family.
This ingratitude is not mere selfishness but treating loyalty as a shackle that can be discarded at any time. In his logic, the relationship between people is merely one of utilization—if the “grace” of his former master can no longer provide protection, it becomes a constraint that must be completely severed through “betrayal” to gain new living space.
Allegorical Analysis
Guard Against the Corrosion of Ethics by “Status Privilege”
Lin’er’s degradation begins with the illusion of privilege brought by his status as a catamite. This reveals a cruel truth: any status privilege lacking restraint (whether derived from power, wealth, or special relationships) will breed arrogance toward rules, ultimately leading to the arrogance and disorder of human nature.
For individuals, treating special treatment as immunity will gradually erode respect for ethical boundaries; for society, allowing “privileged groups” (even dependent ones) to break rules will corrode the entire ethical system, eventually leading to a “might-makes-right” chaos.
Protection by Power Is a “Hotbed of Evil”
Lin’er’s arrogance does not stem from his own strength but from the protection of the censor’s younger brother. This exposes a fatal flaw in the feudal power structure: when power can arbitrarily interfere with justice and shield evil deeds, even the most humble individuals can be incited to extreme malice.
The censor’s younger brother shields Lin’er, essentially treating him as a tool to attack Wu Chengxiu; Lin’er, in turn, transforms this protection into “capital for doing evil,” forming a “symbiosis of evil.” This symbiosis proves that the indulgence of power is never a “personal act” but forms a “chain of evil transmission”—the powerful use the bottomless morality of villain to attack opponents, while the villain satisfy their selfish desires by relying on the powerful, ultimately making the whole society pay the price.
The Ultimate Tragedy – “Tools” Will Eventually Be Abandoned by Power
Lin’er seemingly gains safety by taking refuge with a new master, but in reality, he becomes a “disposable tool” of the censor’s younger brother: his value lies solely in “attacking Wu Chengxiu,” and once he loses this value (or when the conflict escalates to the point of needing a “scapegoat”), he is easily sacrificed (eventually killed by Tian Qilang).
A Dual Mirror of System and Human Nature
What makes Lin’er’s image shocking is that he is not a “born evildoer” but a “specimen of evil” shaped by both the feudal power structure and his own choices: systemic loopholes (power overriding law) provide him with space to do evil, while his opportunism, dependence, and disregard for ethics lead him to actively fall into the abyss.
Leave a Reply