He Lingsi came from a humble background, born into a butcher’s family. She later entered the palace through the imperial selection process and eventually became empress.
However, fate was not always smooth sailing. In the chaotic court struggles, she lost her mother and two brothers. The He family was reduced to just her and her son, Emperor Liu Bian, relying on each other for survival. After the warlord Dong Zhuo entered the capital, the situation became even more complex. He Lingsi’s title of empress dowager and Liu Bian’s title of emperor became meaningless. The mother and son were placed under house arrest and ultimately killed.
In the fourth chapter of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Dong Zhuo poisoned Empress He and Emperor Liu Bian. Empress He fiercely criticized her brother’s foolishness for leading to such a disaster.
“The empress loudly criticized He Jin for his lack of strategy, which led to inviting bandits into the capital and causing today’s calamity.”
— Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Chapter 4
He Lingsi’s troubled fate mirrored the changes in the Eastern Han regime, prompting deep reflection. What should have been an inspirational Cinderella story ultimately ended in tragedy. Was her family’s failure truly due to her brother He Jin’s lack of strategy, or were there other reasons? What lessons can we learn from this historical story?
Superficial blame vs. Deep-rooted problems
Empress He’s complaint essentially placed the direct responsibility for the downfall of the imperial power on He Jin’s decision to invite Dong Zhuo into the capital, ignoring the deeper roots of the collapse of the power structure in the late Han Dynasty. This was a one-sided attribution of blame in a moment of desperation.
Empress He only saw the direct act of inviting bandits into the capital but failed to recognize the root cause—the long-standing struggle between the maternal relatives (represented by the He family) and the eunuch group in the late Eastern Han Dynasty had already exhausted the foundation of imperial power. Even without Dong Zhuo, other warlords would have intervened under the pretext of “cleansing the court.” The essence was the loss of imperial control over local forces, not merely an accidental error of a single decision.
Moreover, Empress He’s complaint was not for the sake of the Han Dynasty but for her own and the He family’s fate. He Jin was her brother. Initially, when He Jin advocated killing the eunuchs, she opposed it because the eunuchs had been her early supporters, indirectly delaying the situation. Now, faced with disaster, she only blamed He Jin for his lack of strategy, reflecting her anger and frustration with her own predicament rather than reflecting on her role in the power struggle.
Reasons for the He siblings’ failure
The core reasons for the failure of Empress He and her brother He Jin in the court struggles were He Jin’s indecisiveness, lack of political strategy, and the siblings’ misjudgment of the threat posed by the eunuch group, coupled with insufficient unity. Specifically:
Failure to identify the main contradiction
The political turmoil in the mid-to-late Eastern Han Dynasty was characterized by the power struggle between eunuchs and maternal relatives. The He siblings’ foundation was “maternal relatives + the young Emperor Liu Bian,” while the eunuch group was a direct threat to this foundation (the eunuchs supported Prince Liu Xie and controlled court power). However, due to bribes from the eunuchs and gratitude for their past help, both Empress He and He Jin compromised on the key decision to kill the eunuchs.
Empress He and other family members obstructed the plan, and He Jin vacillated, essentially prioritizing short-term interests such as harem stability, personal wealth, and sentimental considerations over the fundamental interests of the survival of the maternal relative group and the stability of the young emperor’s throne, thereby abandoning the core goal of the struggle.
Underestimation of the eunuch group’s strength and threat
The siblings underestimated the eunuchs’ (Ten Regular Attendants) strength in the court (e.g., control of the imperial guards, manipulate the emperor) and did not anticipate that the eunuchs would directly resort to assassination, leading to He Jin entering the palace unprepared and dying, causing the collapse of core power.
Internal division among allies
They failed to integrate the natural alliance of “maternal relatives and scholars” (scholar representatives like Yuan Shao and Cao Cao advocated killing the eunuchs). Instead, due to opposition from Empress He, her brother He Miao, and their mother, they hesitated, allowing the eunuchs to detect their plans and preemptively scheme against them, losing the initiative.
He Jin did not heed correct advice, such as Cao Cao’s suggestion to only punish the ringleaders. Instead, they followed Yuan Shao’s advice to completely eliminate all eunuchs in the palace and even blindly summoned external troops like Dong Zhuo to the capital to pressure the Empress He and eunuchs. This not only exposed their weakness but also introduced harder-to-control external warlord forces. Step by step, they expanded the contradictions and enemies. Instead of uniting the many to deal with the few, they united the few to deal with the many.
Empress He’s personal errors
Empress He’s failure had significant personal reasons. The core issue was her lack of political vision, being swayed by immediate interests and personal emotions, ultimately shaking the power foundation of herself and her brother.
Greed for personal gain, tolerance of eunuchs, and weakening of internal alliance
Empress He accepted bribes from the eunuch group and repeatedly obstructed her brother He Jin’s plans to kill the eunuchs, pleading on their behalf. This caused He Jin to vacillate on the decision to kill the eunuchs, missing opportunities. She prioritized personal financial gain over the safety of her family’s power, effectively weakening her own side.
Narrow perspective, focus on harem struggles, and neglect of overall risks
Empress He’s core focus was always on her position in the harem (e.g., suppressing Lady Wang, securing her son Liu Bian’s position as crown prince). However, she failed to see the fatal threat the eunuch group posed to the entire maternal relative force and did not realize that her brother He Jin’s safety directly affected her own survival. Her lack of judgment regarding the overall political situation ultimately led to her and He Jin’s downfall.
Irreversible Historical Trends
If Empress He Lingsi and He Jin had fully cooperated and successfully eliminated the eunuch group, the Eastern Han political situation would have experienced a short-term period of stability under maternal relative control, but it could not reverse the fundamental trend of the dynasty’s decline. In the long run, it would still have moved toward collapse.
Specific developments can be divided into three stages:
Short-term: Maternal relatives solely in power
He Jin controlled the capital’s military power, and Empress He controlled the harem and supported her son Liu Bian (then the young emperor). Together, they could quickly purge the core eunuch forces like the Ten Regular Attendants, avoiding the chaos of He Jin’s assassination and Yuan Shao and Yuan Shu’s massacre of the eunuchs. Court politics would fall entirely into the hands of the He maternal relative group, forming a structure of empress dowager presiding over the court and maternal relatives governing. In the short term, this would end the chaos of eunuch interference and maintain capital stability.
Medium-term: Intensified conflicts with scholars and local warlords
The He group came from a humble background (He Jin and Empress He were from a butcher’s family) and lacked support from the scholar class. After purging the eunuchs, scholar/bureaucratic groups represented by Yuan Shao and Cao Cao would demand a share of power, leading to conflicts with the He maternal relatives. The court would descend into new power struggles.
He Jin had already summoned local warlords like Dong Zhuo and Ding Yuan to the capital (originally to use external force to pressure the eunuchs). Even if the He siblings cooperated, it would be difficult to prevent the warlords’ ambitions after entering the capital. Dong Zhuo and others would not withdraw just because the eunuchs were eliminated but would directly intervene in court politics due to the power vacuum. The He maternal relatives might not be able to control Dong Zhuo, ultimately still leading to a crisis of “Dong Zhuo’s chaotic governance” (though possibly delayed or in a different form).
Long-term: Unchanged trend of dynasty collapse
The fundamental problems of the late Eastern Han Dynasty were land annexation, refugee everywhere, and local powerful families’ separatism. Eunuchs and maternal relatives were only surface-level contradictions. Even if the He group eliminated the eunuchs, they could not solve these deep-seated issues.
If the He group’s conflicts with scholars and warlords intensified, it would still trigger local forces rebelling against the central government. Local lords like Yuan Shao, Cao Cao, Liu Bei, and Sun Jian would expand their power under the pretext of “crusading against maternal relatives/warlords,” ultimately leading to a situation of warlord separatism. The fall of the Eastern Han Dynasty and the arrival of the Three Kingdoms era were inevitable.
Leave a Reply